Shade Gardens: Learning to Love the Darker Side

Apr 2, 2024

“My garden is cursed! All I have is shade and nothing will grow,” wailed the neighbor. Living as we do in “Sunny California,” it may seem downright unfair but almost every garden has some shady spots, and they are often the most troublesome to deal with. And, as buildings get taller and are built closer together, shaded areas are more common and dreams of having verdant outdoor spaces, native plants and pollinators may seem out of reach. But don't despair--gardening successfully in shaded areas requires more planning and proper plant selection but the results are well worth it.

A Few Benefits of Shade
-More water efficiency: shade gardens dry more slowly so plants need less water overall.
-Lower maintenance: plants in shaded areas grow more slowly and therefore require less pruning and deadheading.
-Less fertilizer: because they grow more slowly, shade-loving plants require less frequent applications of fertilizer. A layer of compost and a topping of mulch may be all that's needed.
-Fewer weeds: what we think of as unwanted vegetation usually prefers sunny growing conditions.
-Another reason to lose the lawn: traditional lawn grasses don't usually do well in low light areas. There are plenty of shade-loving ground covers that fill the need for low-growing greenery.

Name Your Shade
There are different types of shade, and the type of shade can change according to the hour and the season. First: spend time observing how much light is present in a particular location, how it changes throughout the day and at different times of the year. This is a crucial step in determining which plants will do well in your garden. From most to least, here are the main categories of shade:
-Full shade: these are places that receive little to no direct sunlight throughout the day. Typical locations for these darker areas are on north-facing sides of a structure, in areas bordered by tall buildings, trees and fences, or spots that are covered by roof overhangs.
-Part shade: locations where sunlight is blocked for a portion of the day by buildings, walls, large trees or natural terrain. As the sun moves from east to west, the light changes as the day progresses. Areas that receive morning light may be shaded in the afternoon and vice versa. In general, east-facing areas that receive morning sun and become shadier in the afternoon are better suited to shade-loving plants. Western facing areas are more likely to receive hot afternoon sun are not suitable and will result in damaged foliage and heat-stressed plants.
-Dappled shade: this usually occurs in areas where overhead tree branches create a mottled pattern of sun and shadow below. The amount of shade will vary according to the type, number, and size of the trees as well as exposure and time of year.
 
Seasonal changes
Shade conditions will also vary according to the time of year. In general, there will be more shade in the winter because the angle of the sun is lower than it is in the summer. Areas that are very shaded in the middle of winter may be a lot sunnier later in the year when the sun is higher in the sky. Just to make things more interesting, places near deciduous trees and shrubs will receive more light in the winter when branches are bare.

Light terminology
When it's time to choose plants for your shaded areas, having a good understanding of terms relative to light will help you make the right choices for your site.
--Full Sun: 6 or more hours of direct sun per day.
--Part Sun: 4 to 6 hours of direct sun, shaded during the most intense sunlight periods/later in the day.
--Part Shade: 4 to 6 hours of sun, preferably morning, shaded the remainder of the day.
--Dappled Sun: A mix of sun and shade throughout the day.
--Full Shade: All plants must have some light but plants that prefer full shade should receive 2 hours or less of direct sun, preferably in the morning.
 
Plant Selection and Planting
There are shade-loving plants that thrive in arid, low water conditions and others that require more moisture. Examine the soil in the shaded areas of your landscape to determine the types of plants that will be best suited. Be sure to choose varieties that have similar requirements and group plants together in the landscape. Once planted, amend the soil with compost and top with a layer of mulch.

Under Trees: To Plant or Not?
While trees provide shaded areas, planting under them is tricky and should be approached with caution. Why? For one thing, the soil under and beyond the dripline of a mature tree will have an extensive root system, which will compete for water, air and nutrients with anything else planted in this area. Most trees resent having their roots disturbed and some, like redwoods, have shallow roots that make planting very difficult. If you want to have a landscaped feel under a tree, an easier option is to plant in pots and place saucers under them.

NOTE: Extreme caution should be exercised before planting anything near a California Live Oak (Quercus latifolia). The roots of these trees are extremely sensitive and even a small amount of added moisture or disturbance can wreak havoc.
Once you have a good fix on the conditions in your location, have fun exploring different options for creating lovely shaded outdoor spaces. In addition to the classics like azaleas, hydrangeas and fuchsias there's a huge variety of plants to choose from.
 
Plant resources
For shade-loving plants native to the Half Moon Bay area and to find planning tools, go to:
 
To find a variety of shade-loving plants that have been tested extensively for durability
and likelihood of success, visit the UC Davis Arboretum All Stars Plant Database at:
https://arboretum.ucdavis.edu/plant-database

Any questions? Contact the Master Gardener Helpline:

-----------------------------------
Maggie Mah is a UC Master Gardener who has a growing appreciation for shade.

UC Master Gardeners of San Mateo-San Francisco County are volunteers who are trained under the auspices of the University of California to provide science-based information on plants, horticulture, soil and pest management at no charge to the public. For more information and to find out about classes and events in your area, visit our website where you can also sign up for our newsletter:
 
Photos courtesy of Thomas M. Johnson

Bleeding Heart” (Dicentra spectabilis), a shade-loving perennial

Bleeding Heart”  (Dicentra spectabilis), a shade-loving perennialPhoto courtesy of Thomas M. Johnson
 
Pineapple guava (Acca sellowiana/Feijoa sellowiana), a hardy member of the myrtle family, is a shrub or small tree that prefers some shade. Fuschia-like blossoms are edible and the fruits taste like a mix of pineapple, kiwi and guava.
Pineapple guava (Acca sellowiana/Feijoa sellowiana), a hardy member of the myrtle family, is a shrub or small tree that prefers some shade. Fuschia-like blossoms are edible and the fruits taste like a mix of pineapple, kiwi and guava.
 
Hostas (Hosta plantaginea) are shade garden classics. Most varieties prefer moist, rich soil.  
Hostas (Hosta plantaginea) are shade garden classics. Most varieties prefer moist, rich soil
 
Hellebores (also known as “Lenten Roses” are shade-loving perennials that bloom from February to May.
April2024 photo 4
 

By Maggie Mah
Author
Topics:

Attached Images: